Evaluating the application of island biogeography theory and

Evaluating the application of island biogeography theory and

Evaluating the application of island biogeography theory and the
effects of insularity in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness
Brian Hull, Alexandra Karosas, Brenna OGorman, and Ernest Ruiz
Faculty Advisor: Dr. Todd Wellnitz
Department of Biology, UW-Eau Claire


Island biogeography explores the factors that may
effect the species richness of islands. Few studies have
been done on the biogeography of the islands in the
Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW), a
federally protected area on the border of Minnesota and
Canada that encompasses 1.3 million acres of pristine
forests, lakes, and islands.

Islands of various sizes and distances from shore were chosen for sampling. Area
and distance were estimated in the field using a map and measured in the lab using
Google Earth .
Woody plants were chosen as the species to sample because of their importance in
providing food and habitats for local organisms.

Our objective was to determine which of two different
theories of island biogeography better describes the
species richness of islands in the BWCAW.

A belt transect was made across the longest part of each island. The transect was
consistently 1m wide and the length of sections doubled continuously, starting with 1m.
The number of different species within each section of the transect was counted and

The Habitat Diversity Theory (HDT) states that the
number of species on an island is a function of the
number of habitats on that island (i.e. larger islands will
have more habitats).

The data from each belt transect was used to calculate species to area ratio. Total
number of species on each island was estimated by taking the largest count of species
for each transect.

The Equilibrium Theory of Island Biogeography (ETIB)
states that the species richness of an island is a function
of immigration and extinction of species, determined by
island size and distance from shore (i.e. the larger and
closer an island is, the more species it will have).
HYPOTHESIS: The HDT will better determine species
richness because more habitats will provide additional
environments for different species to live in. Islands in
the BWCAW do not vary enough in their distance from
shore for the ETIB to be plausible.

Number of habitats were determined by qualitative observation and by comparison of
canopy cover, slope, and analysis of soil samples for pH, conductivity, and % organic

Fig. 6 A view of one of the islands sampled on Ensign Lake.

Island Habitats

As island size
increased, both number
of habitats and species
richness increased

Island Area


Number of





As number of habitats
increased, species
richness increased

Fig. 7 - Sketch of an average habitat layout of the islands.
1: Coastal, low shrubs, sometimes rocky
2: Coniferous trees, sometimes sloped (by varying degrees)
3: Grassy and open, fallen trees, new growth


Distance from

Fig. 1 - Alexandra takes canopy
cover data as Brian counts species.

Fig 2 - Running a transect
through a dense island forest.

Fig 3 - Laying out a belt transect in
a rare open area.

Fig 4 The team chooses islands
to sample.

Fig. 5 Path model representing species richness on 11 islands of the
Boundary Waters Canoe Area as a function of island area, number of
habitats, and distance to nearest shore. Island area positively affected the
number of habitats (r=0.81, P < 0.001) and species richness increased with habitat availability (r=0.53, P < 0.012). Island area also had a direct effect on species richness (r=0.44, P < .038). Distance to nearest shore had no effect on species richness. Model fit: df = 1, GFI = 0.98, P = 0.49. Island size may have had an indirect effect on species richness because of its significant effect on number of habitats. Distance from shore had no significant effect on total number of species. Acknowledgements: Special thanks to Bill Hintz and Dr. Evan Weiher for their help with statistical analysis. Discussion Our data suggests that the Habitat Diversity Theory better explains species richness of woody plants on islands in the BWCAW than the Equilibrium Theory of Island Biogeography. Larger islands contained a greater amount of habitats, providing a more diverse environment and allowing for greater species diversity. Distance from shore had no effect on species richness, likely due to the limited space between islands and the mainland in the BWCAW.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Aztec Gods

    Aztec Gods

    The Aztecs thought that the power of the gods should be acknowledged and thanks given to them, so as to avoid the catastrophes that their rage could cause. For this reason monuments temples and statues were built, and sacrifices performed...
  • My ABC List for Wanted by Sara Shepard

    My ABC List for Wanted by Sara Shepard

    Spencer is also very competitive, some describe her to be the perfect girl. She's pretty, great in sports, and gets perfect grades. T-Trust Trust is what Spencer, Hanna, Aria, and Emily all had with Courtney (their Alison), but the real...
  • Multicriteria Decision Aid: the Outranking Approach Multicriteria decision

    Multicriteria Decision Aid: the Outranking Approach Multicriteria decision

    Different scales. Quantitative or qualitative criteria. Mono- and Multi-decision maker decision problems Mono-decision maker : Single stakeholder (decision maker). Single evaluation table and preference structure. Multi-decision maker: Multiple stakeholders (including decision maker(s)). Multiple evaluation tables and preference structures.
  • READING QUIZ Which of these isotopes is a

    READING QUIZ Which of these isotopes is a

    Uranium spontaneously decays into Barium with some characteristic half-life, even if there is no neutron beam. FISSION Barium-142 and krypton-91 are two possible fission fragments produced when a neutron is absorbed by uranium-235, causing a fission reaction. Nuclear energy comes...
  • Procurement Services Department Training Contact Information (A.K.A. The

    Procurement Services Department Training Contact Information (A.K.A. The

    The total contract value is the initial contract period, plus any options to renew, or the total potential purchase price of an item. This includes shipping, handling, warranties, maintenance & support, convenience fees, reimbursable expenses, in short - ANY cost...
  • Proposal GS1 - Daum

    Proposal GS1 - Daum

    비즈니스 환경 변화 비즈니스 Needs Value Chain의 해체 및 재통합 Globalization (조달, 생산, 분배의 세계화) 기업의 Virual Corporation화 Bussiness Process Outsourcing Knowledge-Based Society 산업간 Boundary의 붕괴 및 융합 Beyond Supply Chain Value Chain Management Win-Win Partnerships 불확실성 및 ...
  • test


    The extent to which past performance evidences that the proposed project will result in timely development (2pts) * Location of Project in RCs/EZs/EC-IIs: Renewal Community Empowerment Zone Enterprise Community Designated in Round II by USDA RC Tax Incentive Utilization Plan...
  • Intel (2017) - Chillin&#x27;Competition | Relaxing whilst doing ...

    Intel (2017) - Chillin'Competition | Relaxing whilst doing ...

    Intel (2017) "where the undertaking concerned submits… that its conduct was not capable of restricting competition and, in particular, of producing the alleged foreclosure effects… the . Commission is .. required to analyse, first, the extent of the undertaking's dominant...