Marxist Theories of IR - University of Nottingham

Marxist Theories of IR - University of Nottingham

Marxist Theories of IR "The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles." (The Communist Manifesto) Introduction Key figures: Marx, Engels and Lenin Key concepts of Marxism for IR Influence of Marxism on IR Critiques of Marxism Is Marxism obsolete?

Conclusion Karl Marx (1818-1883) Family: German Protestant Jews Lawyer, journalist, doctorate on Greek political thought

Young Hegelian The Communist Manifesto with Engels in 1848 coinciding with 1848 revolutions across Europe Refuge in Paris, then London Led First International (working mans association) See Francis Wheens biography Friedrich Engels (1820-1895).

Son of German industrialist Managed fathers cotton factory in England Long political collaboration with Marx Key works: The Condition of the Working Class in England The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State Marxs philosophy Key influences: Hegelian idealism dialectical thinking Feuerbachs materialism Criticises one-sideness of both idealism and materialism

His historical materialist approach attempted to overcome the one-sideness of both idealism and materialism Key to overcoming one-sidedness of idealism and materialism by testing ideas in revolutionary or practical-critical activity i.e .political and social experiment Marxs critiques of Idealism and Materialism Works exploring Marxs critiques of idealism and materialism and attempts to overcome dualism of base v

superstructure etc e.g. Franz Jakubowskis Ideology and Superstructure in Historical Materialism, Pluto, 1990 the man who knows reality no longer stands outside history like Hegels philosopher but is himself a factor in transforming social relations. Theory no longer merely exists post-festum but becomes a lever in the revolutionary process. (Jakubowski, 1990, p. 61). Consciousness and Being

It is not the consciousness of men that determines their existence, but their social existence that determines their consciousness. Marx, 1856 Preface to The Critique of Political Economy What does Marx mean? Aristotle on humans as social beings by nature Modern theories on the development of human consciousness Link to tool use see e.g. Voloshinovs linguistic theories see e.g. Raymond Tallis The Hand History making subjects

Historical/dialectical materialism Human agency in human-made material conditions Men make their own history, but they do not make it just as they please, they do not make it under circumstances chosen by themselves, but under circumstances directly encountered, given and transmitted from the past Marx, Brumaire mans consciousness not only reflects the objective world but creates it Lenin, Philosophical Notebooks Marxs Theory of Alienation

Marxs Theory of Alienation whom am I now to believe, political economy or ethics? ... It stems from the very nature of estrangement that each sphere applies to me a different and opposite yardstick ethics one and political economy another; for each is a specific estrangement of man and focuses attention on a particular field of estranged essential activity, and each stands in an estranged relation to the other. Human Needs & the Division of Labour, Marx 1844 See Istvan Mezaros Marxs Theory of Alienation , Merlin Books, 1970 http:// www.marxists.org/archive/meszaros/w orks/alien/index.htm

Dialectical approach From Hegels dialectics Dialectics as understanding of social relations in motion e.g. value only value if in motion Dialectical historical development: thesis, antithesis, synthesis Contradictory forces and relations under capitalism social production v private appropriation of

profit socialising v alienating aspects of capitalism Contradictory character of capitalist commodity production Commodities as use values v exchange values Commodification everything becomes a commodity including human life Products may be socially wanted but particular social groups in need may not be able to buy them E.g. famine politics

problems E.g. housing Contradictory character of capitalist production Social production i.e. groups of workers producing things for others not for themselves Private appropriation profits going to owners of factories not to factory workers Contradictory character of money

gold as money form Particular commodity v universal value in exchange Capitalism as value in motion Money form (currency, credit etc) easing circulation operation of market not the same as barter economy every sale does not necessarily lead to purchase new purchase potential hiatus in circulation E.g. current credit crunch Vladimir Lenin (1870-1924)

Key figure in 1917 Russian Revolution Leader of Bolshevik Party Key works: Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism State and Revolution What is to be done? Lenin- Imperialism: Highest Stage of Capitalism

Imperialism = monopoly stage of capitalism Concentration of production & creation of monopolies Contradictions of monopoly v free trade Dominance of finance capital Export of capital not just goods Different from earlier empires and even earlier European colonial rule Lenin- Imperialism: Highest Stage of Capitalism Lenin quotes Cecil Rhodes in 1895:

The Empire is a bread-and butter question. If you want to avoid civil war, you must become imperialists. John Hobsons Imperialism, A Study, 1902 Lenins work drawing upon Hobsons work Large extracts in Lenins Imperialism

Fate of Lenins Imperialism imperialism became a generic term with little content.the category imperialism was extended to cover almost any relationship of subordination or control. Today, Lenins grounding of imperialism in issues of the boardroom has been almost entirely forgotten (Lewis and Malone in Lenin, 1996, p. xiii). Common criticisms of Marxism

utopian ignores conventional struggles for power and security arising in anarchical system (Ken Waltz) economic determinism (Martin Wight) over-estimation of class political struggle working class not revolutionary underestimated nationalism criticisms underscored by Marxist concepts becoming rigid Responses to criticisms

Economic determinism? Various Marxist strands downplay dialectics and suggest causal determinism But dialectical method - understanding relations as in motion, involving contradictory relations and forces not simple static, causal determinism Equating theoretical approach with results of approach at particular historical moment Most criticisms merely state the obvious that the world is not the same as when [they] wrote (Lewis

and Malone in Lenin, 1996, p. xiii). Marxisms influence on International Relations theories Influence on International Political Economy and development theories Modernisation theory as response to Marxism Rostows Stages of Economic Growth: A Non-Communist Manifesto, 1960 Dependency or Underdevelopment theories Andre Gunder Frank, Samir Amin, Raul Prebisch

Gramsci and Neo-Gramcian theories World-systems theories Immanual Wallerstein Post-colonial theories e.g. Edward Saids Orientalism, Culture and Imperialism, Hardt and Negris Empire Continuing influence on critical theories e.g. concepts of agency, emancipation etc Dependency or underdevelopment

theories Key theorists: Andre Gunder Frank, Samir Amin, Raul Prebisch Formal political control (colonialism) not necessary to create dependency, possible through economic means

Uneven development and underdevelopment Capitalism leading to uneven development and hindering development of developing countries Not opposed to industrialisation But entanglement of industrial sectors with foreign capital relations Seek strategies to develop independent national economies free from international capitalist political economy. Relevance of Marxist theories today?

Relevance of Marxist theories of class struggle, capitalism, imperialism, militarism to international politics today? How do we understand humanitarian intervention? e.g. Bosnia, Kosovo How do we understand global governance? e.g. Bosnia, Kosovo economic drain rather than economic extraction Why invade Iraq if could better dominate a country and extract more profit with formally independent state without costs of occupation? Responses Dialectic understanding of social relations v Marxs particular analysis of social relations under capitalism in particular period Dialectic analysis of social relations in motion will not be same as Marxs analysis

of 150 years ago E.g. Marxs analysis of idealism in German Ideology perhaps more relevant than Capital in explaining todays international humanitarian interventions. Further reading and resources E.g. communist manifesto in cartoon version that I told you about: http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=znMkqEnO6d4 E.g. Reading Marxs Capital with David Harvey 13 2-hour podcast lectures http://davidharvey.org/

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Monday Jan. 16 Chapter 15 rm 357 Threshold

    Monday Jan. 16 Chapter 15 rm 357 Threshold

    Fig. 15.6 Effect of action potential frequency Contributes to muscle tension Summation of muscle contractions Unfused tetanus for normal conditions Smooth contraction because of asynchronous firing of different motor neurons and tension averages.
  • Control Systems - Islamic University of Gaza

    Control Systems - Islamic University of Gaza

    The degree to which changes in system parameters affect system transfer functions, and hence performance, is called . sensitivity. A system with zero sensitivity (that is, changes in the system parameters have no effect on the transfer function) is ideal....
  • Which Theory Best Explains Human Behavior?

    Which Theory Best Explains Human Behavior?

    As long as harmony in the group occurs, self-actualization is not needed. Behavior Theory. We behave the way we do because we were reinforced at a young age to do so through rewards and punishments. ... Which Theory Best Explains...
  • Embedded System Design - Clarkson University

    Embedded System Design - Clarkson University

    Wireless Sensors and Wireless Sensor Networks (WSN) Darrell Curry Overview Advantages of Wireless Sensors Typical Wireless Sensor Hardware Applications IEEE 802.15.4 ZigBee Demos Advantages of Wireless Sensors Much cheaper to deploy than wired sensors Sensor nodes can be added or...
  • Importance of Entrepreneurship Education - INDIA TRUST

    Importance of Entrepreneurship Education - INDIA TRUST

    Importance of Entrepreneurship Education Entrepreneurship is a key driver of our economy. Wealth and a high majority of jobs are created by small businesses started by entrepreneurially minded individuals, many of whom go on to create big businesses.
  • Essentials of Sociology: A Down-To-Earth Approach

    Essentials of Sociology: A Down-To-Earth Approach

    The Economy: Historical OverviewLearning Objective 12.1: Summarize historical changes to the economy. The economy operates in a predictable manner. Goods and services ensure survival, make life easier, and contribute to social identity. Economies of modern high-income nations are the result...
  • Congestive heart failure Dr. Jamal Dabbas Interventional cardiologist

    Congestive heart failure Dr. Jamal Dabbas Interventional cardiologist

    NYHA class. Characteristics. Class I. No limitations of physical activity; no symptoms of CHF. Class II. Slight limitations of moderate or prolonged physical activity (e.g., sympt
  • ADDIE Model, the Interservices Procedures for Instructional ...

    ADDIE Model, the Interservices Procedures for Instructional ...

    ADDIE Model, Interservices Procedures for Instructional Systems Development Model, and Dick and Carey Model :A Study in Similarities and Differences in Major Instructional Design Models EDTC 6321 Group 2 : Joshua McDonald. Kristina Hamilton. Rodolfo Ramirez. Shannon Reynolds. Welcome to...